Page 1 of 1
vynabond vs. 3m Urethane epoxy for D-rings?
Posted: Tue Oct 26, 2004 10:34 pm
by sbroam
There is NO vynabond in this town! One outfitter suggested 3m urethane epoxy - is this a good idea for D-rings on royalex?
Posted: Tue Oct 26, 2004 11:35 pm
by yarnellboat
If you can't find Vinylbond (the product here is VinylTec 2000) for your d-rings-on-vinyl-patches, then maybe you can find non-patch d-rings?
You know those d-rings - a metal D that fits under a hard, plastic strip. If you are attaching those types of d-rings then the 3M epoxy is great.
P.
NO to epoxy!!!
Posted: Wed Oct 27, 2004 12:23 am
by OC1_SURFER
I have outfitted and reoutfitted several royalex canoes. Most of the boats that I have purchased have been used. One of the biggest problems I have encountered in reoutfitting a used WW canoe is eliminating the old epoxy that the previous owner has unwittingly used to glue his D-rings, toe blocks, knee boots, etc. As far as I know, there is no solvent that will dissolve epoxy. You do get a strong bond with it, however if you ever want to change positions of your outfitting, you're screwed! I usually end up taking a Dremel with a small grinding bit and just smoothing it out. It is very easy to go too far with it though. That inner layer of hull vinyl is pretty thin.
I only use vynabond for my vinyl D-rings and other vinyl outfitting (contact cement for minicell). A vynabonded D-ring is relatively easy to remove. Just heat it with a hair dryer and then pull it off with a pair of pliers. And there will be very little residue.
Whenever I'm in a WW shop, I always stock up on vynabond if they have any. Some shops don't even carry it anymore. If you can find it, I suggest forgetting the epoxy. You'll be doing yourself a favor, as well as the next owner of the boat. Who knows, the next owner might be ME!
T.P.
Posted: Wed Oct 27, 2004 12:30 am
by Larry Horne
I remember having bad luck with the hard plastic d-rings and 3m.
I think NRS and NOC have vynabond.
Posted: Wed Oct 27, 2004 12:36 am
by sbroam
Thanks - that's kind of what I thought. I've always had good luck with Vynabond and only used the epoxy once in a boat with the polycarbonate (?) d-ring mounts and that later broke! Oh, I did use PC-7 to put D-rings on my Pelican box. Besides, the guy (his name is actually "Guy") who was recommending the epoxy is not exactly reliable...
Come to think of it, I did have some Vynabonded d-rings fail once - the vinyl layer of the *royalex* pulled away from the *ABS*...
Another outfitting Q coming up...
Scott
Posted: Wed Oct 27, 2004 1:36 am
by yarnellboat
Sounds like good advice on the d-rings - the epoxy is a nightmare to remove!
Come to think of it, I did have some Vynabonded d-rings fail once - the vinyl layer of the *royalex* pulled away from the *ABS*...
Make certain to allow sufficient drying time for the adhesive, otherwise it continues to "gas" and effects the Royalex as you said. I'm sure somebody has a better explanation.
P.
Posted: Wed Oct 27, 2004 1:46 am
by sbroam
I've always used two coats and taken a hair dryer to the two surfaces before bringing them together - I think I got that out of an NOC catalog once. I've also heard of excess Vynabond softening a hull to near failure.
The failure I experience was from leaving fully inflated bags in the boat, on my truck, in the SC summer heat. There were webbing straps retaining the bags clipped to d-rings on the hull. They peeled away, taking the vinyl with them... Yes, I felt stupid
Posted: Wed Oct 27, 2004 2:20 am
by pevans
When I talked to Mohawk canoes they used DAP contact in the red can (the green is water soluable) and I've never had any problems in my probe. I dont know how well this would work on the hard based d-rings though.
Good luck,
Paul
Vynabond
Posted: Wed Oct 27, 2004 4:27 am
by billcanoes
Scott,
I know you want the vynabond to get you boat ready for GAF- I'm pretty sure I have a tube I can bring with me- I might be doing the tuck on Fri..??? maybe we can meet there so you can start your outfitting??? I bought 10 tubes from NOC and have 2 left,
I'm also meeting a friend tomorrow at lower green who lives in greenville- not sure how far that is for you??? Call my cell early tomorrow and I'll give it to her. Or you could stop by tomorrow in Charlotte after 6
I'll bring the vynabond with me tomorrow - either doing Lower Green Upper Green or Park and Play at French Broad 6-
Oh- you might also want to check pool supplies- they sometimes carry vynyl adhesive, in a blue and white tube which is supposed to be vynabond in a different package- I bought this in Charlotte and it was $4.95 a tube instead of $2.95. It worked.
704-604-6687 --
Bill
lo and behold
Posted: Thu Oct 28, 2004 11:15 am
by sbroam
Lo and hehold, I went to the shop myself and rummaged around on my own and what did I find - 2 tubes of vynabond. Now the boat is in much better shape for his inaugural Nantahala float!
Posted: Fri Oct 29, 2004 3:32 am
by ezwater
What is this 3M "epoxy"?? I have 2 part 3M urethane structural adhesive, have used it to glue in pedestals and some d-rings, though for d-rings I'm happy to use Vynabond. \
I have West epoxy, but would never use epoxy for glueing d-rings or fittings. I do use West for putting layered glass cloth graunch pads onto ABS boat ends, AFTER stripping the vinyl layer off the ABS. Epoxy bonds better to ABS than to vinyl.
Posted: Fri Oct 29, 2004 9:20 am
by sbroam
g2d wrote:What is this 3M "epoxy"?? I have 2 part 3M urethane structural adhesive, have used it to glue in pedestals and some d-rings, though for d-rings I'm happy to use Vynabond.
It's probably not "epoxy" but what you named - I got the name over the phone from a questionable source, not off of a label. I just use the DAP contact cement for pedesdals and pads on both vinyl and PE.